Placeholder Photo

Who is the real Arthur???


Much excitement abounded last Summer as we finally, after a protracted chase, secured brazillian midfielder Arthur Melo. Some said we were getting a steal – a Xavi like young talent in exchange for Pjanic in a deal which seemed to help us more than Barcelona, who were involved in a fire sale of sorts to desperately try balance the books. Others said he was a Barca reject, whose hype had not at all being justified, and the move was mainly a mutually agreeable creative accounting routine.

The player we then saw this last season proved impossible to judge. Used in a muddled midfield system, where nobody looked decent other than in spurts; Arthur also suffered many injuries. Had no chance to gain any momentum in the often disjointed tactical soup.

He remains, for me and likely many others a player who it is hoped could well feel like a new signing this coming season. With a highly experienced coach and likelihood of a settled set of tactics, we need the Brazillian to find his rhythm and form. For all we have seen so far is brief flurries of a high octane recycler of the ball, impressively press resistant, but little else beyond.

Heading back to mid 2020, I have delved into the reports of some Barca platforms to learn more.

“He is an extraordinary footballer who understands everything.”

The words of former Barca coach Quique Setién, who was evidently keen to make Arthur a mainstay of his side. Though for balance, back then, after what proved the player’s only solid run of form for the Catalans, before his sale to Juve, even Setien also noted that he was a ‘long term’ prospect, not the finished article.

All the below is taken from >>

After arriving at Barcelona for € 31 million in summer 2018, Arthur has been a regular starter for Barcelona whenever he’s been fit and available. Known for his vision and gifted ability to play in possession, Barcelona’s quest to find another ‘Chameleon Eyes’ ended up in Arthur. 

Arthur has featured as an eight for Barcelona although he played as a defensive midfielder in Gremio. His heatmap suggests his preference and the area of operation lies to the left predominantly, inclining towards the centre. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

The claim, until now, seems to be justified. Despite starting fewer games due to injuries this season, Arthur still places himself into an elite category when it comes to pass completion rates, forward passes and attacking moves when compared to midfielders around Europe’s major leagues. The attributes that Arthur stands out in – getting hold of the ball, moving the ball horizontally as well as vertically and maintaining passing accuracy seem to match Setién’s possession-based approach perfectly. With 90.88% pass completion, Quique Setién can see a reliable carrier of the ball in his functioning possessional play. Similarly, the diagram below further justifies that Arthur consistently ranks among the best central midfielders in attacking attributes. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

After a stellar first season under pragmatic Ernesto Valverde, Arthur has sprung into action this season despite missing a handful of matches due to injuries. However, the young Brazilian has evolved a lot in this period of time and has hence made noticeable evolution in his gameplay and attributes. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Comparing his attributes for the 2018/19 season (left) and the current season (right), Arthur’s all-round development can be observed. During 2018/19 and half of the current season at Barcelona, Arthur played under a comparatively pragmatic system, thereby not allowing him to freely make use of his playmaking abilities. Similarly, Barcelona were often dominated by sides with higher pressing lines, making it even more complex for the Brazilian to open up and maintain the tempo of the possession.

However, after 11 appearances under Setién, Arthur’s xG per 90 and xA per 90 have climbed, indicating the Brazilian can yield numbers under a system that he fits in. Similarly, the total xG of possessions that have Arthur’s involvement has seen an increase, suggesting Arthur will be a vital weapon to create goal-scoring chances and split defences in the coming future. 

Quique Setién’s system and Arthur’s positioning superiority 

‘Arthur is Barcelona’s next Xavi.’ Everyone that has observed Arthur Melo hold the ball, turn and pass the ball comes to a prediction about Brazilian’s close resemblance to the Blaugrana legend. The similarity becomes even more obvious when we consider Setién in this equation as Xavi, who rose to the throne under Guardiola, played under the same ideology that Setién had re-ignited to the Camp Nou. 

In simple terms, keeping the ball with you, hiding it from the opponent, tempting the opponent and opening up spaces to penetrate is what Juego De Posicion is based on. Setién’s approach of football requires technically gifted and positionally aware players to work at its fullest. Arthur in this regard is one of the most prolific and compatible players that we can find today.

 Barcelona’s system includes the formation of little triangles throughout the opposition pitch when in possession, to positionally create advantage and multiple passing options for everyone with/around the ball. Creating triangles contribute to better ball protection, a better connection via midfield to explosive forwards like Luis Suarez, Antoine Griezmann and Lionel Messi. Hence, the need for a midfielder that can balance the time and space equation is inevitable. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

As a player who loves to demand and work with the ball, Barcelona with Arthur can have a player that can spot players when he’s on the ball, as well as position himself for the ball carrier to spot him. Possession-based Barcelona tend to rely a lot on reducing spaces while they penetrate in the opposition half and Arthur, with and without the ball, is able to reduce space between him and his potential passing option with the ball. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Similarly, without the ball, Arthur tries to get into the centre of the pitch, from zone 10 towards zone 11 to get as close to the ball as possible. As a result, we can see a healthy interchanging of passes between effective zone 14 players like Lionel Messi and Arthur whenever the former Gremio man is on the pitch for Barcelona. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Arthur’s positioning is a quality that Quique Setién will be excited to exploit more and use him to mature even more. However, provided that Arthur is just 23 and can still develop as a player, Quique Setién will be looking forward to injecting positional discipline to reduce chances of getting caught in midfield during counters. 

Building from the back and Arthur’s role 

Quique Setién’s side and Barcelona, in general, are known for building out from the back. However, any team like Barcelona should have an adaptational alternative option that should be present to counter how oppositions press. Since Barcelona do not have players that possess superior physique to receive aerial balls from the keeper during the buildup, the side has to find a man who receives from the centre as the centre-backs draw the pressing opposition players. 

In many regards, Arthur can be a player that is able to play with interchanging player positions, can hold the ball and find options using pauses and turns. Hence, for Quique Setién’s adaptational approach, Arthur’s capabilities fit in. With high pressing sides like Getafe prominent in the league, Setién’s advent to domestic superiority can be enhanced with a profile like Arthur (or even Frenkie de Jong). 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Similarly, the use of width via horizontal play helps a lot to stretch the defence and find spaces to penetrate. Lack of a midfielder that is not able to spot and use horizontal spaces to shift play can result in a complete system failure. The missing piece of the puzzle here, for Setién’s Barcelona, can be Arthur, who is able to detect the runs and spaces created by out of position players.

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

In the instant shown above, Arthur demonstrates a perfect-fit skill set, drawing players towards him. This might seem risky to execute but Arthur’s repetitive practice and his talent let him do these more often. Drawing the players entirely to his left side, he creates a trap for himself which he can use to his team’s advantage. He does so by detecting the space created on the other side and the run-making teammate, Lionel Messi. By making a pass to the space, Arthur is able to effectively create a lethal finishing situation that will yield a high xG for a player of Messi’s calibre. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Similarly, Arthur is able to combine with his corresponding full-back to organize supply from the wide areas in addition to the diagonal balls we talked about earlier. Since Quique Setién has diverse options to choose from, Arthur has made several cameos from the left side under Setién, as a midfielder that supplies forward more than the other side occupied by Ivan Rakitic. Hence, not only does the ability to execute diagonal passes comes vital but Arthur’s awareness of managing to spot the run making full-backs that are free will be vital for Setién’s horizontal route to move the opponent structure. 

Arthur’s possessional skills and attacking capability

Coming from the land that accumulates dazzling and skilful attackers, Arthur Melo is unique due to his technicality that almost makes him resemble a European midfielder. Abilities such as the use of the body to deceive opponents, use of pauses and faints to open spaces as well as interchanging passes to get rid of central blocks make him a system player tailor-made for Barcelona. Under Quique Setién, he can further display his charisma as the tenure has just started. 

What makes him promising is his ability to maintain pass accuracy despite being one of the players that attempt the most number of advanced passes while on the pitch. Arthur boasts 67.8 passes per 90 with an accuracy of 91.75% (a Xavi-esque figure). 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics
Arthur’s zonal pass completion and passing sonar. [Credit:]

Looking at the pass distribution around the pitch and accuracy, it’s fair to conclude that Arthur is a versatile midfielder inside the Setién’s system. The deficiency of passes in the final third and zone 14 are because of the pragmatic system that restricted midfield effective connection from midfield to attack as well as may well be because of attackers themselves coming deep to fetch passes and drive forward. 

Similarly, Arthur, in addition to a capable playmaker, is an attacker that is able to make runs, penetrate and shoot as well. Against tight teams that defend in numbers and man-mark the forward players, Arthur can be a surprise element that triggers runs and shoots. This will add to Setién’s approach of avoiding predictability and inducing dynamism in attacking schemes. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Arthur’s dribbles in the final third clear the case and ensure the idea of him as an attacking element. The 23-year-old has 20 successful dribbles in the final third, with a success rate of 83%. The remarkable thing here is that the dribbles normally come as an advanced pass for the fellow player, or a shot at goal. With this level of awareness of when to go out for a shot and when to pass, Arthur truly holds a place at Setién’s Barcelona and promises to strengthen Barcelona side. 

Similarly, the Brazilian is often seen making progressive runs whenever he gets the ball with the space in front of him. In this case, the Brazilian bursts into a run, allows attackers to come to support him and make the most out of the situation. This awareness not only allows Barcelona to take advantage of space ahead but puts them in advantage higher up the pitch on counters. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

In the instant shown above, Arthur is seen receiving the ball around the middle of the pitch. Notice that there is a vertical space in front, and Arthur makes the most of the space that is formed by horizontal movement of opposition defence. In the meantime, Martin Brathwaite makes runs drawing defenders towards him, freeing Arthur to execute a one-two with him. The move ends with an Arthur Melo goal. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

A player who can execute ‘La Pausa’ yet drift into spaces and compensate for run making forwards to arrive and deliver can definitely be an asset to a Total Football disciple like Setién. Hence, Arthur can see himself staying, despite all the speculations in the air. 

The de Jong – Arthur co-existence  paradox 

Another talent that made his way into the Barcelona side this summer was Frenkie de Jong, one of the most technically gifted midfielders of this generation. After playing as a double-pivot in Ajax’s fairytale season and displaying a mouth-watering performance throughout the season, Frenkie has finally met a coach of his type in Quique Setién. The question here is, can Frenkie and Arthur exist in the same team under Setién? 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

The question comes from the fact that both the players resemble each other so much when their attributes are compared. In a 4-3-3, both Arthur and Frenkie have started out as an eight and prefer to be an eight in that formation. With Arthur’s injury concerns, Quique Setién too has opted for a midfield of Frenkie de Jong, Sergio Busquets and Ivan Rakitic more often. Hence, on papers, it is difficult to adjust both the players in the same team, especially for building a system, not a team full of stars. What seems clear, as of now, is that Arthur Melo is favourable than the current starter Ivan Rakitic and can be an option provided that Setién benches Rakitic and integrates both de Jong and Arthur in the team. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

With Sergio Busquets a permanent figure as the sole defensive midfielder as of now, opting for a 4-3-3 will see both Arthur and Frenkie start as an eight and a ten respectively. This instance was experimented by Setién against Getafe, where he started de Jong towards the right. Against a high pressing Getafe, the scheme was successful and the Blaugrana were able to nullify Getafe’s approach. 

Arthur at Barcelona 2019/20 - scout report - tactical analysis tactics

Ideally, a defensive midfielder like Busquets, a ball carrier like either de Jong or Arthur and an attacker like Carles Alenya or Riqui Puig with an electrifying physical midfielder like Arturo Vidal coming from the bench would be perfect on paper. However, considering the fact that Xavi and Iniesta too were once regarded to have too many similarities between them, we’ll have to wait and see how Setién incorporates and manages de Jong and Arthur. It all comes down to the manager’s approach now, how he will make the most out of two of the most talented and potential midfield stars in years to come for Barcelona. 


Quique Setién’s love for Arthur is obvious: he sees him as a part of his plan. Barcelona, after multiple attempts to replace Xavi, have finally found a profile that can provide them with a benchmark to midfield dominance yet again. What makes it more obvious is that they’ve found a manager who loves to dominate the pitch, play the ball quickly and get every ounce of what his technical players have for him. 

As the tactical analysis pointed out, Arthur certainly has the Barca DNA that fans have waited after Xavi’s departure. For now, Quique Setién will be home, figuring out his chess-led philosophies to make the most out of his team and uplift the system using the man himself: Arthur Melo. 

Great analysis! Now back to me…

Clearly he does have playmaking abilities, they just need to be strategically deployed rather than assuming just put him anywhere in the middle and he will be amazing. The high level passing quality and ability to create chances and split defences is precisely what the side has been lacking for too long, since Pjanic was a better player. And yet this only works, prove a value IF we have players making intelligent runs to break the lines and across the final third, which we rarely have had for some time, I would suggest since Ronaldo appeared and the tactical focus moved too much onto making the most of his elite talents in and around the box.

It is likely that this was another reason why we failed to see the best of Arthur. Having a specialist creative force in the final third, asking him to play deeper, and lacking runners to hit ahead of him, we would expect to see him buzz around and play lots of quick passes horizontally. He needs movement ahead of him, which we only truly saw with mega fluidity in the final league game against Bologna with Ronaldo absent and Morata, Chiesa, Dybala, Kulu running riot (absent of Arthur)…This is also why the midfielders generally looked poor on the whole, as they either are not equipped to take on numerous opponents and drive all the way to goal, or had nobody to pass to ahead of them. I very much hope, close to assume, this will change with Max, Though fear, this much needed evolution of our system hinges upon Ronaldo leaving the ranks.

I liked what I saw of Arthur even in brief snippets, for players capable of moving the ball intelligently, swiftly as well as turning in miliseconds away from danger are rare and precious commodities in any era of the game. This is something I have seen in few players, at Juve or elsewhere. Added to his passing ability, it means that he is able to draw opponents to him, confident to keep the ball, which unlocks space for others to then be found by Arthur or when he has traded off the ball via others.

There are demonstrable reasons, in the analysis above, as to why Arthur has been often looking like becoming a superstar, not just for Barca, Gremio before, but also for Brazil, who are for me, still the best national side on the planet.

This is from way back in 2017, more words on Arthur Henrique Ramos de Oliveira Melo>

(taken from

The 21-year-old has already made into a Brazil squad, and though he’s yet to make the Selecao, that he’s in the picture at his age while still plying his trade in Brazil says a lot about his talent. He’s the youngest domestic based player to be called up to the squad in recent times, and one of the youngest full stop, with only 20-year-old Manchester City striker Gabriel Jesus and 21-year-old Monaco left-back Jorge of his age or younger receiving Brazil call-ups in 2017.

Tite thinks so highly of Arthur because of the way he is able to control the midfield on both sides of the ball.

The Brazil coach recently went to watch Arthur play in a match between Gremio and Botafogo, and returned with a glowing report.

“When I went to the game, I wanted to see the atmosphere,” said Tite.

“The emotional side, the pressure of it all, where you could size up the environment in which the kid was playing so naturally. I cannot close doors to a player in a team where he is so important despite his age.”

As well as being mentally strong, he’s one of the more reliable players when it comes to fitness too, having played more minutes than any other Gremio player in the Brazilian league this season.

He boasts a pass accuracy of 93%, the highest in his team, and operates as both a deep lying and advanced playmaker. He regularly has more touches of the ball than most of his team-mates, and spreads these out equally in both halves of the pitch.

The example below shows his touches of the ball from Grêmio’s game against Corinthians. Looking at this image it would be impossible to tell which way his side were attacking, such is the range of touches in both halves (Grêmio were attacking right to left, and those touches in his own area are clearances).

While he does have a good positional awareness when it comes to defending, and averages two tackles and one interception per game this season, there is no doubt that his skills lie in the control of the game through possession and the building of attacks.

Here’s an example taken from Grêmio’s Copa Libertadores semi-final second leg against Barcelona (Ecuador). He receives the ball under pressure, but he beats the first man with his first touch as he lets the ball run across his body, then slices the opposition in half with a pass through to the striker with the outside of his right boot.

He’s the man who makes the pass before the assist, or even the one before that, and obligatory comparisons with current or recent stars have labelled him the new Thiago Alcântara, or Andrés Iniesta. Comparisons are helpful to see what type of player a young footballer has the potential to be, but while they are handy for the observer they can place huge weight on the player’s shoulders.

However, these tests are always a good indication of whether a player can cope with the pressure and go on to forge their own identity rather than constantly be compared to others, and along with the likes of Gabriel Jesus, Neymar, and Philippe Coutinho before him, Arthur could do just that.

“I do not know if, in nine months from now [at the World Cup], he will have a place [in the Brazil squad],” added Tite.

“But he is a prospect for the future. I can compare him now to where Gabriel Jesus was.”

This comparison is apt, despite the players’ different positions, and it suggests that Arthur is a move to the right club in Europe away from furthering his development and receiving another call-up which leads to a first cap.

But it has to be the right club. The timing of Jesus’ move to Manchester City was perfect as he is the ideal player for Pep Guardiola, as Arthur himself may also be. With Fernandinho advancing in years, and Yaya Touré seemingly on his way out, the young Brazilian could be the Catalan manager’s alternative to İlkay Gündoğan in the midfield hub.

Name: Arthur Henrique Ramos de Oliveira Melo
Foot: Right
172cm 5’8”
Comparisons: İlkay Gündoğan, Thiago Alcântara, Andrés Iniesta

We have a rare and precious talent in Arthur. Who could play a key role in quickly reviving our fortunes, to what level I am unsure, but suffice to say, if Max can play to his strengths, Mr Arthur Henrique Ramos de Oliveira Melo could prove pivotal and a legacy of Paratici’s haphazard endeavour who blossoms into a top class catalyst to unlocking the certain potential of that Chiesa-Morata-Dybala-Kulu offensive skillset.

(follow the site on twitter HERE)